Best All-Season Tyres for Your Car in 2023/24
Ellie Dyer-Brown, 1 year ago
5 min read
- Tyres
- Review
FixMyCar recommends the best all-season car tyres for every budget.
Overview:
Best premium all-season tyre - Michelin CrossClimate 2
Best mid-range all-season tyre - Hankook Kinergy 4S 2
Best budget all-season tyre - RoadX Rxmotion 4S
The convenience of all-season tyres has made them an increasingly popular choice for UK drivers who want to avoid the cost and hassle of having two sets of tyres - one for summer, the other for winter.
Compared with the prospect of changing four tyres every six months - or paying someone else to do it for you - keeping the same ones all year round is an unsurprisingly attractive prospect.
When relying on a single set of tyres, it’s even more important to choose the right ones. That’s where this guide comes in. It contains something for every budget, from premium brands like Michelin to more affordable alternatives like RoadX.
Contents:
How are all-season tyres tested?
How are all season tyres tested?
Testing all-season tyres is similar to winter tyres since both have to perform in harsh and often slippery conditions.
Generally, testers select a reproducible driving manoeuvre - such as braking from a particular speed to a standstill - and test each tyre’s ability in three conditions: wet, dry and snow. This testing process is usually done without ESP stability control.
The main performance areas for tyres are:
Braking
Noise
Fuel economy
Aquaplaning resistance
Our methodology
We don’t conduct tyre tests at FixMyCar. Instead, we analyse test data from industry-leading publications like Auto Express, combining it with information from expert and driver reviews to create a broader picture of how each tyre performs.
Best premium all season tyres
Here are our top picks in the premium category. Check out this guide for more information about premium tyres and whether they’re worth it.
Michelin CrossClimate 2
The Michelin CrossClimate 2 is one of the most popular all-season tyres, revered by industry experts and everyday drivers.
Features
Thermal adaptive tread compound to cope with variable road conditions.
V-ramp tread blocks maximise ground contact for better dry braking.
V-shaped grooves ensure efficient water evacuation for excellent wet braking.
Steps on block improve traction in snowy conditions.
Ratings
Some ratings vary between different sizes.
Wet grip - B
Fuel efficiency - B/C
Noise - A/B
Performance and awards
The CrossClimate 2 has won a slew of awards from across the industry. It came out on top in both the Tyre Reviews’ 2022/23 All-Season Tyre Test and the 2023 Auto Bild All-Season Tyre Test, where it beat Continental’s offering and earned a Green Tyre Award in the process.
Additionally, Auto Zeitung gave it a fuel-saving recommendation in the same year.
In Auto Express’s 2022 All Season Tyre Test, the CrossClimate 2 came in 2nd place, behind a tyre by mid-range rival Hankook. Nevertheless, it scored 99.8% overall, with 100% in the snow braking, snow traction, snow handling, dry braking and rolling resistance categories.
On Tyre Seeker, drivers have awarded the CrossClimate 2 a rating of 4.6 stars based on 202 reviews at the time of writing. Its highest scores are:
Wet grip - 93%
Buy again - 93%
Dry braking - 93%
Wet braking - 92%
Dry grip - 92%
Comfort - 92%
Together, these numbers show excellent all-round performance.
Not only is the CrossClimate 2 recommended by Tyre Seeker, but it also won the site’s 2022 All-Season Tyre Test in winter conditions.
Why you should buy it
This is the one to buy if snow performance is a concern, but you don’t want to buy a set of winter tyres. Although its wet performance isn’t quite as outstanding, the CrossClimate 2 is a superb all-season tyre that can easily handle the transition between seasons.
Continental AllSeason Contact 2
Continental is the first brand drivers often think of when buying a new set of tyres. With over a century of tyre-making experience and numerous awards to show for it, it’s hardly surprising that the AllSeason Contact 2 is one of the most talked about tyres in this category.
You can read our review of Continental tyres here.
Features
Adaptive tread design lowers abrasion, extending its lifespan.
Energy-efficient materials for reduced rolling resistance and fuel consumption.
Chili Blend compound provides consistent safety.
Multiple C-shaped blocks for extra stiffness and efficient water displacement.
Ratings
Wet grip - B
Fuel efficiency - B
Noise - B
Performance and awards
In the 2023 Auto Bild All-Season Tyre Test, the AllSeason Contact 2 came in 2nd place and earned an “exemplary” rating, offering “an efficient all-season solution for drivers of all vehicle types”. It delivers a 15% increase in mileage and 6% less rolling resistance, combined with its award-winning predecessor's already high safety standards.
The AllSeason Contact 2 put its best performances into the following categories: snow traction, wet braking, noise and rolling resistance, making it an excellent value premium tyre overall.
Why you should buy it
In polling conducted by Auto Bild in 2023, drivers voted for Continental as the best brand in the winter, summer and all-season tyre categories, proving how highly motorists regard the brand. For safety and reliability - crucial attributes in all-season tyres - it’s tough to beat.
Bridgestone WeatherControl A005 EVO
In many ways, Bridgestone’s WeatherControl A005 EVO tyre is the exact opposite of the CrossClimate 2: at home in the wet but struggles in the snow. It provides a highly comfortable ride.
Check out this Bridgestone tyres review for more information.
Features
High volume slots in the tread pattern ensure best-in-class wet grip.
Renewed Nano Pro-Tech compound works with innovative sipes for improved traction in the snow
Optimised carcass construction allows the tyre to withstand challenging weather conditions while preventing uneven wear.
Ratings
Wet grip - A
Fuel efficiency - C
Noise - B
Performance and awards
The WeatherControl A005 EVO came 3rd in the 2022 Auto Express All-Season Tyre Test, earning a total score of 99.7%. Its outstanding wet grip rating shone through in test scores, achieving 100%. Its weakest score was 79% for curved aquaplaning.
Drivers also approve of the A005 EVO, giving it 4.6 stars on Tyre Seeker based on 199 reviews at the time of writing. 93% said they would buy the tyre again, awarding it 90% for dry grip and 91% for comfort.
Why you should buy it
The WeatherControl A005 EVO is a well-priced tyre that maintains tremendous grip in the wet, delivering a quiet and comfortable ride. Though it came 3rd in the Auto Express test, there was very little between the top three tyres.
Goodyear Vector 4Seasons Gen-3
The third generation of the Vector 4Seasons doesn’t disappoint, particularly in wet conditions. With a good grip and fantastic aquaplaning resistance, it is the ideal choice for motorists concerned about safety when there’s water on the road.
You can learn more about Goodyear in our brand review.
Features
Deeper and broader grooves for better aquaplaning resistance.
Many sipes at the centre of the tread for better snow grip.
Durable compounds and strong shoulder blocks prevent deformation during heavy manoeuvres.
Ratings
Wet grip - B
Fuel efficiency - C
Noise - B
Performance and awards
The Vector 4Seasons Gen-3 came 4th in the 2022 AutoExpress All-Season Tyre Test with an overall score of 99.1%. It excelled on wet road surfaces, efficiently handling deep water, though its performance on snow could have been more impressive.
It did better in the 2023 Tyre Reviews All-Season Test, earning 2nd place behind the Michelin CrossClimate 2 - a worthy adversary. Wet and dry handling and comfort were its strongest areas, though it came 10th out of 12 for price.
The Vector 4Seasons Gen-3 finally saw a breakthrough in the 2023 Auto Zeitung All Season Tyre Test, where it took the top spot, beating tyres by Michelin and Hankook. It was praised for its strong performance across all criteria, and this enthusiasm is mirrored by drivers, who have awarded it 4.7 stars on Tyre Seeker based on 187 reviews at the time of writing.
Why you should buy it
The Goodyear Vector 4Seasons Gen-3 is a capable all-season tyre, ideal for the UK climate, which sees a lot of rain and little snow.
Best mid range all season tyres
Below, you can find our recommended mid-range tyres.
This guide discusses whether mid-range tyres are any good.
Hankook Kinergy 4S 2
The Kinergy 4S 2 by mid-range brand Hankook is an accomplished all-season tyre: quiet, balanced and a pleasure to drive. With outstanding wet and dry handling, excellent value for money and a reliable grip on snow, this is easily one of the best all-season tyres.
Take a look at this brand review for more information about Hankook.
Features
Wide lateral grooves provide improved drainage performance.
A two-step aqua slant drains water efficiently while retaining the tyre’s stiffness.
High-density summer sipes and enhanced block stiffness offer better driving performance.
A concave tie bar improves block stiffness by 4%.
Ratings
Wet grip - B
Fuel efficiency - C
Noise - B
Performance and awards
The Kinergy 4S 2 came first in the Auto Express All Season Tyre Test 2022 with a superb overall score of 100%. Its individual test scores show precisely why this tyre triumphed:
Dry handling - 100%
Cabin noise - 100%
Snow circle - 100%
Wet handling - 100%
Snow braking - 99.3%
Few all-season tyres are as accomplished across the board.
When Tyre Reviews put 12 all-season tyres to the test, the Kinergy 4S 2 came 3rd, with the best dry handling, shortest wet braking distance and a high level of comfort. For this reason, it comes highly recommended by the review site.
On Tyre Seeker, at the time of writing, drivers have given the Kinergy 4S 2 a rating of 5 stars based on four reviews, with 100% for value, comfort and buy again.
Why you should buy it
The Kinergy 4S 2 has one of the most consistent all-around performances of the tyres covered in this guide, and it also comes with a reasonable price tag, making it a fantastic choice for drivers who don’t want to compromise.
Avon AS7
Avon has been making waves in the world of tyres recently, creating affordable and performance-driven products. The AS7 is a perfect example of this winning combination.
Read our Avon tyres review for more information about the brand.
Features
Lateral 3D sipes and grooves provide excellent wet braking and water evacuation.
All-season silica and resin technology for reliable grip, no matter the temperature.
Durable compounds ensure impressive wear results.
Ratings
Wet grip - B
Fuel efficiency - C
Noise - A
Performance and awards
While Hankook flirts with the boundary between mid-range and premium, Avon sits firmly in the former category, which helps to contextualise its position in the Auto Express 2022 All-Season Tyre Test: 7th (last).
However, against an array of premium tyres by some of the best brands in the business, the fact that the AS7 featured at all is impressive. Yes, it came last against a group of mostly premium tyres, but it was the cheapest in the lineup and is by far one of the best in the mid-range category.
The AS7 had an overall score of 97%, with perfect results for straight and curved aquaplaning (both 100%). Other notable scores include 99.9% for cabin noise, 98.3% for dry handling and 94.6% for snow circle; this is a quiet tyre that is exceptionally safe in the wet. It is also three-peak mountain snowflake certified.
At the time of writing, drivers have awarded the Avon AS7 4.6 stars out of 5 on Tyre Seeker based on 82 reviews, with first-rate scores of 91% for dry braking, comfort and buy again, and 90% for wet braking.
Why you should buy it
The AS7 is a great all-rounder, providing safety and performance for a reasonable price. Whether driving in snow or heavy rain, it’s a tyre you know you can rely on.
Best budget all season tyres
These are the best options for cost-conscious drivers. Read this guide to find out whether budget tyres are any good.
Budget Tyres Greenwing AS
The Greenwing AS is designed with affordability in mind. It provides a reasonable level of grip and safety regardless of season, though it doesn’t match the performance levels of more expensive all-season tyres.
Features
Unique tread compound for grip through winter and summer.
Tread design precisely engineered to expel water.
Asymmetric tread pattern optimised for handling.
Ratings
Wet grip - C
Fuel efficiency - C
Noise - B
Performance and awards
On Tyre Seeker, drivers have awarded the Greenwing AS a rating of 5 stars at the time of writing based on five reviews. Its highest scores are:
Value - 100%
Buy again - 100%
Comfort - 100%
Wet grip - 68%
These scores reflect the strengths and weaknesses of budget tyres: they are cheap, offering good value, but cannot compete with more expensive tyres in performance-related categories.
If winter safety is your primary concern, it may be worth exploring mid-range tyres for extra peace of mind.
This tyre has not won any awards.
Why you should buy it
The Greenwing AS is a comfortable tyre that makes driving easy in favourable conditions. It is also reasonably cheap, taking pressure off your wallet.
RoadX Rxmotion 4S
The Rxmotion 4S is another budget tyre worth mentioning. It has a good grip in the dry and decent grip in the wet, though you’ll have to put up with significant road noise.
Learn more about this budget brand in our RoadX tyres review.
Features
Optimised tread pattern for reliable grip and increased wear resistance.
Versatile silica compound to boost wet weather traction.
S-shaped grooves to efficiently drain water.
Ratings
Wet grip - C
Fuel efficiency - D
Noise - B
Performance and awards
Unlike its premium rivals, the Rxmotion 4S isn’t well known. However, drivers on Tyre Seeker have rated it 4.5 stars at the time of writing based on eight reviews. So far, it scores 100% for dry and wet grip and 87% for value and buy again.
Tyre Reviews has put it in 57th place out of 67 all-season touring tyres - an expected result for a budget tyre competing against premium giants like Bridgestone. If you’re looking for better performance but want to avoid an inflated price tag, mid-range tyres may be worth your consideration.
Why you should buy it
The Rxmotion 4S’s stability and handling make it a decent budget tyre for getting you from A to B. Your wallet will thank you for it, but your car’s overall performance may take a hit, especially when the weather is at its worst.
Buy a set of all season tyres
Ready to buy a set of all-season tyres? FixMyCar is here to help, providing the best brands and a network of mobile and garage fitters at your fingertips.
If you found this guide helpful, you might also like:
